SNES/Sega CD, 1993
Truth be told, there's no reason why every EA Sports game 10 years and older shouldn't already be cleaned up and ported to consoles right now. They could make a killing selling just old downloadable Madden games alone. But even better, EA could put all of its classic sports titles as downloads on Wiiware, PSN, XBLA and even the Nintendo 3DS store, sell them for $5, and make a mint.
But, if there was only one EA Sports game allowed to grace today's consoles, NHL 94 should be it. It introduced the keeping of records, and the one-timer and knocking opponents into the bench, hats being thrown on the ice after a hat trick, the bright flash of the lamp after a goal, the organ music were all beautiful to see. Best. Sports game. Ever.
Chances You'll Ever See a Modern Port: 65%